- RussKeymasterJanuary 3, 2015 at 10:54 pmPost count: 124
The old adage goes, “Buy the coin, not the slab!”. This thread will serve to illustrate when TPGs miss the mark, or the target altogether. The purpose here is not to badger the TPGs for making a mistake, but rather to help hone the skills of the coin collector. Be keen!
In general, Indian Head Cents that are in encased by NGC as part of the Stack’s W 57th St Collection are overgraded. Some perhaps deserved a details grade in my own opinion. Look over these coins carefully.
Here is one to get us started an AU53 by NGC that is more like an XF40.
Collecting Flying Eagle and Indian Head pennies never made more cents!DVCollectorModeratorJanuary 4, 2015 at 1:51 amPost count: 103
I see an ~XF45. I don’t even think AU unless I can see a good amount of luster, which is absent in the pictures.
Unless I’m not seeing a better variety, I don’t understand why they would slab an IHC worth maybe $7.50…RussKeymasterJanuary 14, 2015 at 8:04 pmPost count: 124
Wow, this must be one of the most overgraded coins I’ve seen by any TPG.
Collecting Flying Eagle and Indian Head pennies never made more cents!DVCollectorModeratorJanuary 14, 2015 at 8:18 pmPost count: 103
By my standards, that might hit 35-40–details. I think I see more than a few corrosion spots.RussKeymasterJanuary 15, 2015 at 11:16 amPost count: 124
OMG, just wow. I guess I spoke too soon. From what I’ve seen over the last couple of years, I’m not sure I’d include NGC in the top three TPGs anymore… for Indian Cents at least. PCGS and ANACS do a far superior job. In fact, it seems ANACS is the most accurate and consistent for grading, but prices favor PCGS. Just my take.
Collecting Flying Eagle and Indian Head pennies never made more cents!
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.